1
00:00:00,250 --> 00:00:01,167
by two separate
yet equally important groups,

2
00:00:05,505 --> 00:00:07,424
the police
who investigate crime

3
00:00:07,465 --> 00:00:10,301
and the district attorneys
who prosecute the offenders.

4
00:00:10,343 --> 00:00:12,470
These are their stories.

5
00:00:12,512 --> 00:00:14,806
My baby,
I can't wake him.
He's not breathing.

6
00:00:14,848 --> 00:00:16,015
Was he choking?
I don't know.

7
00:00:16,057 --> 00:00:17,976
I came to
change his diaper,
and he wouldn't wake up.

8
00:00:18,018 --> 00:00:19,310
This kid wears diapers?

9
00:00:19,394 --> 00:00:20,895
He's a quadriplegic.
Help him!

10
00:00:20,937 --> 00:00:21,855
Get an airway.
Right.

11
00:00:21,896 --> 00:00:23,690
Can I get a hand with the O2?
Got it.

12
00:00:26,735 --> 00:00:28,320
Here we go.
Pupils fixed.

13
00:00:28,361 --> 00:00:30,447
You got a...
No, nothing.

14
00:00:30,488 --> 00:00:33,867
This kid's blue.
Temp is way down.

15
00:00:33,908 --> 00:00:35,035
Mom, what's wrong
with Mikey?

16
00:00:35,076 --> 00:00:36,453
I don't know, honey.

17
00:00:36,494 --> 00:00:37,912
This kid's gone.
Still nothing.

18
00:00:37,954 --> 00:00:38,913
You're not giving up!

19
00:00:38,955 --> 00:00:40,290
We're not stopping.

20
00:00:40,332 --> 00:00:41,541
Three, four, five.

21
00:00:41,583 --> 00:00:43,418
There's something wrong here.

22
00:00:43,460 --> 00:00:44,919
I think you need
to call Homicide.

23
00:00:44,961 --> 00:00:46,546
Increasing the rate.

24
00:00:50,550 --> 00:00:51,801
Are you guys
the detectives?

25
00:00:51,843 --> 00:00:53,428
We're undercover.

26
00:00:53,470 --> 00:00:55,472
Special jaywalking
duty on 14th Street.

27
00:00:55,513 --> 00:00:57,932
He's got writer's cramp.
Must've given out
20 tickets.

28
00:00:57,974 --> 00:00:59,476
What's this about?

29
00:00:59,517 --> 00:01:02,687
Michael Sutter, 12.
His mother says he was
paralyzed from the neck down.

30
00:01:02,729 --> 00:01:06,066
She's the one that
called 911 at 5:17.

31
00:01:06,107 --> 00:01:08,568
The paramedics
pronounced him dead.

32
00:01:08,610 --> 00:01:11,529
So a sick kid dies.
Why call us?

33
00:01:11,571 --> 00:01:13,656
Ask him.
Check his lips.

34
00:01:13,990 --> 00:01:15,033
Blue tint.

35
00:01:15,075 --> 00:01:19,079
Cyanosis. Kid's got
micro-hemorrhaging
in both eyes.

36
00:01:19,120 --> 00:01:21,122
Suffocated?
Looks that way.

37
00:01:21,164 --> 00:01:22,207
No, you're wrong.

38
00:01:22,248 --> 00:01:25,418
You must be wrong.
Nobody could have
done that.

39
00:01:25,460 --> 00:01:27,837
I was alone with him
all afternoon.

40
00:01:27,879 --> 00:01:30,882
Why don't you
take Mrs. Sutter and her
daughter to the living room?

41
00:01:34,052 --> 00:01:36,346
Did I just
hear a confession?

42
00:02:26,688 --> 00:02:31,151
Michael used to be
all straight As.
Played soccer.

43
00:02:31,192 --> 00:02:34,112
But then
Dad took him
skiing two years ago.

44
00:02:34,154 --> 00:02:37,032
They were driving back,
and hit some ice.

45
00:02:37,073 --> 00:02:40,660
There was only
one airbag. Dad's.

46
00:02:40,702 --> 00:02:43,621
Was anybody else here
when your mother
found Michael?

47
00:02:43,663 --> 00:02:46,833
Just Mom. We don't
get a lot of company.

48
00:02:46,875 --> 00:02:48,126
What about your dad?

49
00:02:48,168 --> 00:02:50,962
He was working.
On Long Island.

50
00:02:51,004 --> 00:02:53,048
He's a landscape engineer.

51
00:02:53,089 --> 00:02:55,425
And where were
you this afternoon?

52
00:02:57,510 --> 00:03:02,766
After school, I hung
out with some friends,

53
00:03:02,807 --> 00:03:06,144
and then I had to
pick up some groceries.

54
00:03:06,186 --> 00:03:09,939
Then I came home, and...

55
00:03:11,149 --> 00:03:12,609
And he was...

56
00:03:12,651 --> 00:03:15,653
Michael's care is your
mother's responsibility?

57
00:03:15,695 --> 00:03:19,115
The insurance
stopped covering
the health care worker,

58
00:03:19,157 --> 00:03:21,659
so Mom had to quit
her counseling job.

59
00:03:21,701 --> 00:03:23,703
Your mom
get along with Michael?

60
00:03:23,745 --> 00:03:26,748
Nobody gets along
with Michael.

61
00:03:26,790 --> 00:03:29,042
His brain was
like a baby's.

62
00:03:31,169 --> 00:03:34,464
We were at
the hospital today.

63
00:03:34,506 --> 00:03:37,509
Every Tuesday
he goes for dialysis.

64
00:03:39,052 --> 00:03:41,721
We came home around 3:00.

65
00:03:43,223 --> 00:03:47,185
He fell asleep on
the way back in the van.

66
00:03:47,227 --> 00:03:51,564
And from 3:00
until you found him,
did you check in on him?

67
00:03:53,191 --> 00:03:57,862
Do you do this kind
of questioning after
every family tragedy?

68
00:03:57,904 --> 00:03:59,823
Only when we need answers.

69
00:03:59,864 --> 00:04:03,284
So you never went out
for coffee or anything?

70
00:04:03,326 --> 00:04:05,120
I went to
pick up the paper.

71
00:04:05,161 --> 00:04:07,163
I wasn't gone more
than five minutes.

72
00:04:07,205 --> 00:04:08,665
And nobody dropped by?

73
00:04:08,707 --> 00:04:10,083
Nobody.

74
00:04:10,125 --> 00:04:13,670
You take care of
your son by yourself.
You gave up your career?

75
00:04:14,170 --> 00:04:15,588
It was no sacrifice.

76
00:04:15,630 --> 00:04:18,258
You were holed up
with your kid for
two years.

77
00:04:18,299 --> 00:04:19,968
You couldn't have
been too happy about it.

78
00:04:20,009 --> 00:04:21,928
What are you saying?

79
00:04:22,637 --> 00:04:24,597
You think I killed him?

80
00:04:26,141 --> 00:04:28,059
Michael was my son.

81
00:04:29,144 --> 00:04:31,604
He was a sick little boy.

82
00:04:31,646 --> 00:04:35,775
He just died.
God just took
my boy away!

83
00:04:39,070 --> 00:04:40,280
Kid was a quadriplegic.

84
00:04:40,322 --> 00:04:41,865
Could he have just
stopped breathing?

85
00:04:41,906 --> 00:04:44,117
The M.E. says that
if somebody hadn't
suffocated him,

86
00:04:44,159 --> 00:04:46,161
he would've
kept on breathing
for another 60 years.

87
00:04:46,202 --> 00:04:49,122
And there were no marks?
No abrasions around his
mouth or nose?

88
00:04:49,164 --> 00:04:52,042
No. It wouldn't have
taken much pressure.
Probably a pillow.

89
00:04:52,083 --> 00:04:56,880
M.E.'s preliminary report
sets the time of death
around 3:30, 4:00.

90
00:04:56,921 --> 00:04:59,883
Well, the call to
911 came in at 5:17.

91
00:04:59,924 --> 00:05:01,885
That gives
Mom plenty of
time to clean up.

92
00:05:01,926 --> 00:05:03,261
So the mother
might have tampered

93
00:05:03,303 --> 00:05:05,013
with evidence that
might have existed.

94
00:05:05,055 --> 00:05:07,599
Unless somebody
came in while she was
out getting the paper,

95
00:05:07,640 --> 00:05:09,184
and did her the favor of
killing the kid.

96
00:05:09,225 --> 00:05:12,729
Well, so far,
she's the only one
with the boy all afternoon.

97
00:05:12,771 --> 00:05:15,815
Did he get any kind of
insurance settlement?
Maybe in trust?

98
00:05:15,857 --> 00:05:18,068
Single car accident.
Nobody to sue.

99
00:05:18,109 --> 00:05:21,154
The insurance covers most
of the medical bills,
but that's it.

100
00:05:21,196 --> 00:05:22,322
What's the daughter think?

101
00:05:22,364 --> 00:05:24,324
That Mom's not
a happy camper.

102
00:05:24,366 --> 00:05:25,909
See if Mr. Sutter agrees.

103
00:05:26,910 --> 00:05:30,246
And, guys, about this
jaywalking assignment,

104
00:05:30,288 --> 00:05:31,206
it came from the top.

105
00:05:31,247 --> 00:05:33,917
It's all about my
lawsuit. I'm sorry.

106
00:05:36,836 --> 00:05:40,715
It's not natural, picking
out a casket for your son.

107
00:05:40,757 --> 00:05:43,843
Salesman starts
telling me about
mahogany and hardware,

108
00:05:43,885 --> 00:05:46,805
like I'm comparison
shopping or something.

109
00:05:46,846 --> 00:05:48,807
We appreciate how
hard this is for you.

110
00:05:49,557 --> 00:05:51,309
Mrs. Sutter,
she was the one

111
00:05:51,351 --> 00:05:52,852
who usually took
care of Michael?

112
00:05:52,894 --> 00:05:55,647
Well, I did
what I could
on the weekends.

113
00:05:55,689 --> 00:05:58,858
Was your wife
resentful about
being stuck at home?

114
00:05:59,818 --> 00:06:02,946
You know,
Lois warned me
about you guys.

115
00:06:02,987 --> 00:06:05,824
Look, if she were happy
about it, she'd be a fool.

116
00:06:05,865 --> 00:06:07,701
She quit being
a social worker,

117
00:06:07,742 --> 00:06:09,119
I quit going
for overtime,

118
00:06:09,160 --> 00:06:12,789
which has
made us practically broke,
as I'm sure you know by now.

119
00:06:12,831 --> 00:06:14,666
Mr. Sutter,
we're trying to be fair.

120
00:06:14,708 --> 00:06:17,335
But your wife was home,
and your son was murdered.

121
00:06:17,377 --> 00:06:18,628
I don't believe that.

122
00:06:18,670 --> 00:06:20,797
Well, can you
think of anyone else who
would want to hurt Michael?

123
00:06:20,839 --> 00:06:23,133
Nobody wanted
to hurt Michael.

124
00:06:23,174 --> 00:06:26,678
I mean, maybe
somebody broke in
when Lois stepped out.

125
00:06:26,720 --> 00:06:27,846
Tried to rob the place.

126
00:06:27,887 --> 00:06:28,930
There was no sign of that.

127
00:06:28,972 --> 00:06:31,057
I mean, you didn't find
anything missing, right?

128
00:06:31,099 --> 00:06:33,977
Anyone outside
of your family have
a key to your apartment?

129
00:06:34,019 --> 00:06:35,895
There's our neighbors,
the Hodges.

130
00:06:35,937 --> 00:06:39,816
I think they still have a key.
But they didn't kill Michael,
either.

131
00:06:40,442 --> 00:06:42,319
He was a nice boy.

132
00:06:42,360 --> 00:06:46,448
You know, Joe blamed himself
for what happened, driving
so fast.

133
00:06:46,489 --> 00:06:48,658
Next drawer over.

134
00:06:48,700 --> 00:06:50,702
Joe saved
the boy's life.

135
00:06:50,744 --> 00:06:52,871
Gave him CPR
for half an hour.

136
00:06:52,912 --> 00:06:54,748
Could the key be missing?

137
00:06:54,789 --> 00:06:57,167
No, no, no.
It's in here someplace.

138
00:06:58,501 --> 00:07:01,338
Did you see any of the
Sutters Tuesday afternoon?

139
00:07:01,379 --> 00:07:04,132
I said hi when
Lois brought Michael
home from the hospital.

140
00:07:04,174 --> 00:07:05,258
I was on my way out.

141
00:07:05,300 --> 00:07:08,887
Tuesdays it's ceramics,
and today it was art class.

142
00:07:08,928 --> 00:07:12,307
I tried
to encourage
Lois to do that.

143
00:07:12,348 --> 00:07:15,351
Bridge, book club,
something.

144
00:07:15,393 --> 00:07:19,105
I know she started
going to a dance studio
right around the corner.

145
00:07:19,147 --> 00:07:23,193
She needs to get out.
No one should have
such tsuris.

146
00:07:23,234 --> 00:07:24,778
Here it is.

147
00:07:24,819 --> 00:07:27,822
She was pretty bitter, huh?
Alone with Michael all day?

148
00:07:27,864 --> 00:07:29,324
She seemed
happier lately.

149
00:07:29,366 --> 00:07:32,827
That's the makeup.
She started painting
her face again.

150
00:07:32,869 --> 00:07:35,246
Can't change the inside,
you change the outside.

151
00:07:40,085 --> 00:07:42,212
Would you two like to
be fixed up with partners?

152
00:07:42,253 --> 00:07:46,841
No, we're together.
You have a student
named Lois Sutter?

153
00:07:46,883 --> 00:07:50,553
Lois? Yes. Yes.
She comes every
Friday afternoon.

154
00:07:50,595 --> 00:07:52,097
How long she
been coming here?

155
00:07:52,138 --> 00:07:53,848
About three months now.

156
00:07:53,890 --> 00:07:55,809
Quite talented. She's
moved up to intermediate.

157
00:07:55,850 --> 00:07:58,144
I mean, really,
she's a natural
at salsa and tango.

158
00:07:58,186 --> 00:08:00,397
Any particular student
she's friendly with?

159
00:08:00,438 --> 00:08:03,108
I couldn't say.
I teach beginners.

160
00:08:03,149 --> 00:08:07,028
Mr. Gilbert teaches
the Latin steps,
but he's off today.

161
00:08:07,070 --> 00:08:07,946
I'm sure he'd know.

162
00:08:07,987 --> 00:08:10,240
He sometimes
shares a cab
with her.

163
00:08:10,281 --> 00:08:13,952
Excuse me.
Something I really
have to put a stop to.

164
00:08:13,994 --> 00:08:16,287
She shares a taxi for
a half-a-block ride?

165
00:08:16,329 --> 00:08:20,125
I'm guessing
Gilbert's bedroom's
a little further away.

166
00:08:20,208 --> 00:08:22,919
Who I share a taxi with
is none of your business.

167
00:08:22,961 --> 00:08:25,213
And I haven't
done anything improper
with any of my students.

168
00:08:25,255 --> 00:08:27,924
Maybe we should
get them all together
for a teacher evaluation.

169
00:08:27,966 --> 00:08:29,843
Yeah, women are
a little harder
to charm

170
00:08:29,884 --> 00:08:32,220
when they find out they're
number 12 in the conga line.

171
00:08:32,262 --> 00:08:34,347
I teach dance. It's sensual.

172
00:08:34,389 --> 00:08:36,391
It's only natural
that bonds would form.

173
00:08:36,433 --> 00:08:37,851
With Lois Sutter?

174
00:08:37,892 --> 00:08:41,479
Mr. Gilbert,
we're not the press corps,
and you're not the President.

175
00:08:41,521 --> 00:08:42,480
We need an honest answer.

176
00:08:42,522 --> 00:08:45,900
It's not
what you think.
We've grown very close.

177
00:08:45,942 --> 00:08:47,986
Close enough she'd share
confidences about her family?

178
00:08:48,028 --> 00:08:50,363
Yes.
I'd say her husband
doesn't understand her,

179
00:08:50,405 --> 00:08:52,032
but Lois's husband
doesn't even know her.

180
00:08:52,073 --> 00:08:53,825
What about her son?
She talk about him, too?

181
00:08:53,867 --> 00:08:55,326
Husband, son,
her daughter.

182
00:08:55,368 --> 00:08:57,203
She wanted out
of that situation.

183
00:08:57,245 --> 00:08:58,621
She told you that?

184
00:08:58,663 --> 00:09:01,875
Foreplay generally
consisted of letting
her vent for half an hour.

185
00:09:01,916 --> 00:09:03,918
When she was
here on Tuesday,
it was the same drill.

186
00:09:03,960 --> 00:09:05,920
This Tuesday? What time?

187
00:09:05,962 --> 00:09:08,965
She came by mid-afternoon,
around 3:30.

188
00:09:09,466 --> 00:09:10,925
She left at 4:40.

189
00:09:10,967 --> 00:09:12,927
You seem pretty sure
about the time.

190
00:09:12,969 --> 00:09:14,554
Well, she
looked at her watch.
She said she had to go.

191
00:09:14,596 --> 00:09:15,972
Anybody see you two together?

192
00:09:16,014 --> 00:09:17,974
Well,
the whole point
was not to be seen.

193
00:09:18,016 --> 00:09:19,559
She checked
her watch, huh?

194
00:09:19,601 --> 00:09:21,895
Guess you couldn't
have been all that good.

195
00:09:24,230 --> 00:09:25,899
Please don't
tell my husband.

196
00:09:25,940 --> 00:09:27,859
It'll just kill him.

197
00:09:27,901 --> 00:09:28,818
Tell him what?

198
00:09:28,860 --> 00:09:31,529
About Gilbert, or
that you killed your son?

199
00:09:31,571 --> 00:09:33,615
I did not kill Michael.

200
00:09:33,657 --> 00:09:37,202
No, you were
too busy doing the
horizontal cha-cha.

201
00:09:37,452 --> 00:09:38,370
Yes.

202
00:09:38,411 --> 00:09:41,664
It's a nice alibi,
but we're not buying it.

203
00:09:41,706 --> 00:09:43,375
You wanted out
of your marriage.
No.

204
00:09:43,416 --> 00:09:48,421
You couldn't stand sleeping
next to a guy who'd turned
your son into a potted plant.

205
00:09:48,463 --> 00:09:49,964
As long as Michael
was still alive,

206
00:09:50,006 --> 00:09:51,383
you didn't have
the guts to walk out.

207
00:09:51,424 --> 00:09:53,635
No. No, please.

208
00:09:53,677 --> 00:09:57,138
How'd you do it?
With a pillow?
A blanket?

209
00:09:57,180 --> 00:09:59,391
Michael just died.

210
00:09:59,432 --> 00:10:02,602
Here's the
Medical Examiner's report.
Read what it says right here.

211
00:10:02,644 --> 00:10:04,979
"Hemorrhaging in
his eyes, cyanosis,

212
00:10:05,021 --> 00:10:07,440
"depleted oxygen
in his blood stream."

213
00:10:07,482 --> 00:10:09,401
You know what that means?

214
00:10:09,442 --> 00:10:10,902
That can't be Michael.

215
00:10:10,944 --> 00:10:12,904
"Michael B. Sutter."
That's your son.

216
00:10:12,946 --> 00:10:15,115
"Death by
manual asphyxiation."

217
00:10:16,449 --> 00:10:18,201
No, it can't be.

218
00:10:19,244 --> 00:10:20,120
That's impossible.

219
00:10:20,161 --> 00:10:22,956
It's right there
in black and white.

220
00:10:22,998 --> 00:10:25,125
She couldn't have.
Who?

221
00:10:27,627 --> 00:10:29,587
I can't believe
she'd hurt him.

222
00:10:29,629 --> 00:10:30,630
Who'd hurt him?

223
00:10:30,672 --> 00:10:32,549
I left him
with Stephanie.

224
00:10:32,590 --> 00:10:33,883
Your daughter?

225
00:10:33,925 --> 00:10:35,885
Oh, God.

226
00:10:40,306 --> 00:10:42,142
I don't care
what you say,
I wasn't home,

227
00:10:42,183 --> 00:10:43,309
and Mom was
watching Michael.

228
00:10:43,351 --> 00:10:46,396
Your mother
spent the afternoon
with her boyfriend.

229
00:10:46,438 --> 00:10:48,523
Now, we don't know
what she told you
she was doing,

230
00:10:48,565 --> 00:10:52,110
but she told us that you
were at home covering
for her.

231
00:10:52,152 --> 00:10:53,695
You killed your brother.

232
00:10:53,737 --> 00:10:55,947
She... She said that?

233
00:10:57,032 --> 00:10:58,533
Why'd you do it, Stephanie?

234
00:10:58,575 --> 00:11:02,454
Were you jealous of
all the attention he got?
All the trouble he caused?

235
00:11:02,495 --> 00:11:03,538
No.
Come on.

236
00:11:03,580 --> 00:11:06,624
The whole family
was falling apart
because of him.

237
00:11:08,460 --> 00:11:10,253
Okay, take it easy,
take it easy.

238
00:11:10,295 --> 00:11:12,714
You're a minor,
your family has
big problems.

239
00:11:12,756 --> 00:11:14,632
The judge is
gonna be sympathetic.

240
00:11:14,674 --> 00:11:15,842
You just have to
tell us what happened.

241
00:11:15,884 --> 00:11:19,095
I mean, your brother was
barely living anyway,
right?

242
00:11:19,137 --> 00:11:23,600
I wasn't there.
I was with Kara
from my bio class.

243
00:11:23,641 --> 00:11:26,311
Your mom's a better liar
than you are, Stephanie.

244
00:11:26,352 --> 00:11:27,645
It's the truth.

245
00:11:27,729 --> 00:11:30,732
My mom was always
sticking me with him.

246
00:11:30,774 --> 00:11:33,068
I mean, all he ever did
was lie in bed.

247
00:11:33,109 --> 00:11:36,112
And all
he ever cared about
was watching TV, eating,

248
00:11:36,154 --> 00:11:37,655
and crapping his pants.

249
00:11:38,365 --> 00:11:40,492
So as soon as my mom left,

250
00:11:42,202 --> 00:11:44,079
I ditched him.

251
00:11:44,120 --> 00:11:48,375
I'm sorry.
I just couldn't stand
to be with him anymore.

252
00:11:50,085 --> 00:11:52,671
Hooked up with
Stephanie around
a quarter after 3:00.

253
00:11:52,712 --> 00:11:53,546
Where'd you go?

254
00:11:53,588 --> 00:11:56,132
The Asteroid Palace,
down on Broadway.

255
00:11:56,174 --> 00:11:57,300
We played
video games.

256
00:11:57,342 --> 00:11:58,510
How long
were you there?

257
00:11:58,551 --> 00:12:00,512
I don't know,
about an hour.

258
00:12:00,553 --> 00:12:02,555
She have anything to
say about her brother?

259
00:12:02,597 --> 00:12:06,184
Steph's always
got something to
say about the vegetable.

260
00:12:06,226 --> 00:12:07,519
That's what
she called him.

261
00:12:07,560 --> 00:12:08,687
He's a pain in the ass.

262
00:12:08,728 --> 00:12:10,772
Why? She used
to trip over him?

263
00:12:10,814 --> 00:12:13,400
Steph and I
were gonna go away
to college together.

264
00:12:13,441 --> 00:12:15,402
Not anymore. No money.

265
00:12:15,443 --> 00:12:17,529
Stephanie was pretty
angry about that, huh?

266
00:12:17,570 --> 00:12:19,489
Look, Stephanie's
not a bad person.

267
00:12:19,531 --> 00:12:22,409
Just nothing ever
seems to go her way.

268
00:12:22,450 --> 00:12:24,452
What was her mood
Tuesday afternoon?

269
00:12:24,494 --> 00:12:26,496
I don't know.
She was fine.

270
00:12:26,538 --> 00:12:30,291
She seem nervous?
Distracted?

271
00:12:30,333 --> 00:12:31,793
Yeah, she was
distracted by one

272
00:12:31,835 --> 00:12:34,170
of those guys that
gives you the quarters.

273
00:12:34,212 --> 00:12:36,423
I think he was
hot for me, though.

274
00:12:37,799 --> 00:12:40,635
Couple of
the arcade workers
confirm the girl was there.

275
00:12:40,677 --> 00:12:41,678
Yeah,
and in high spirits.

276
00:12:41,720 --> 00:12:44,014
Her brother's dead,
all her problems
are solved.

277
00:12:44,055 --> 00:12:46,558
That's pretty cold-blooded.
Is that the kind of girl
she is?

278
00:12:46,599 --> 00:12:48,184
I didn't see a lot
of ice in her veins.

279
00:12:48,226 --> 00:12:51,438
She walked out on her brother.
She's cut from the same
iceberg as her mother.

280
00:12:51,479 --> 00:12:53,565
So the
boy was alone
from 3:00 to 5:00,

281
00:12:53,606 --> 00:12:56,109
which is when
he got murdered.

282
00:12:56,151 --> 00:12:59,529
Go back to the M.E.
Nail down the time
of death.

283
00:13:01,698 --> 00:13:04,326
Forget the time
he actually died.

284
00:13:04,367 --> 00:13:05,827
He was poisoned
two hours before that.

285
00:13:05,869 --> 00:13:07,037
Poison?

286
00:13:07,078 --> 00:13:09,831
When you called,
I had the lab pull out
all the stops.

287
00:13:09,873 --> 00:13:12,542
Kid's tox screens
spiked for nicotine.

288
00:13:12,584 --> 00:13:14,419
I knew he was
a 12-year-old
quadriplegic,

289
00:13:14,461 --> 00:13:16,129
so I figured
he wasn't a smoker.

290
00:13:16,171 --> 00:13:18,298
Unless somebody
was holding the
cigarette for him.

291
00:13:18,340 --> 00:13:19,799
I checked
the intestinal contents.

292
00:13:19,841 --> 00:13:25,180
What we thought were carrots
tested positive for coniine.
Hemlock root.

293
00:13:25,221 --> 00:13:28,058
Poison hemlock?
Isn't that what
Socrates died from?

294
00:13:28,099 --> 00:13:30,143
Forensics says
the stuff grows wild.

295
00:13:30,185 --> 00:13:32,062
Not just in ancient Greece.

296
00:13:32,103 --> 00:13:34,606
Paralyzes the muscles,
and finally the lungs.

297
00:13:34,648 --> 00:13:37,108
Already paralyzed,
nobody'd notice
he was dying.

298
00:13:37,150 --> 00:13:39,736
Nobody'd notice because
no one was watching him.

299
00:13:39,778 --> 00:13:42,655
The kid had lunch
at the hospital
with his mother.

300
00:13:42,697 --> 00:13:43,740
Thanks.

301
00:13:46,534 --> 00:13:48,620
Michael Sutter
came in at 9:30

302
00:13:48,662 --> 00:13:50,372
and was discharged at 2:15.

303
00:13:50,413 --> 00:13:52,332
He was in this room.

304
00:13:52,374 --> 00:13:54,250
It's okay,
you don't have to get up.

305
00:13:54,292 --> 00:13:55,585
So you talked
to Mrs. Sutter?

306
00:13:55,627 --> 00:13:56,711
Yes, about Michael.

307
00:13:56,753 --> 00:14:00,298
Unfortunately, nothing had
changed since the accident.

308
00:14:00,340 --> 00:14:03,760
Mr. Blake, you're not
feeling too dizzy
this afternoon?

309
00:14:04,386 --> 00:14:05,637
Good.

310
00:14:06,513 --> 00:14:08,223
Michael was
a real trouper.

311
00:14:08,264 --> 00:14:10,892
The kind of
damage he suffered
is terribly tragic.

312
00:14:10,934 --> 00:14:14,687
More than Mrs. Sutter
could deal with?

313
00:14:14,729 --> 00:14:17,857
You can't
imagine the pressure
this puts on a family.

314
00:14:17,899 --> 00:14:21,528
If Mrs. Sutter
did do something to
help end her son's pain,

315
00:14:21,569 --> 00:14:24,155
nobody can fault her
for feeling the way
she did.

316
00:14:24,197 --> 00:14:25,782
Did she fix his lunch?

317
00:14:25,824 --> 00:14:28,159
Michael was supposed to
have a hospital lunch.
Why?

318
00:14:28,201 --> 00:14:29,744
The meal may have
been tampered with.

319
00:14:29,744 --> 00:14:32,747
Anyone other than
Mrs. Sutter have
access to it?

320
00:14:32,789 --> 00:14:36,376
Uh, that I don't know.
I wasn't in the hospital
at lunchtime.

321
00:14:36,418 --> 00:14:39,796
Oh. Here we go.
Michael had his
usual meal at 1:00.

322
00:14:39,838 --> 00:14:42,298
One of
the candy stripers
would've delivered it.

323
00:14:42,340 --> 00:14:46,386
My school's vocational program
lets me work here two days
a week.

324
00:14:46,428 --> 00:14:47,679
I hope I'm not
in any trouble.

325
00:14:47,721 --> 00:14:48,888
No, no trouble, Martha.

326
00:14:48,930 --> 00:14:52,851
Did you keep an eye
on your food cart
last Tuesday?

327
00:14:52,892 --> 00:14:53,852
I don't watch it
all the time,

328
00:14:53,893 --> 00:14:56,688
but I just leave it
alone in the corridor

329
00:14:56,730 --> 00:14:58,773
for a sec when I'm
in the patient's room.

330
00:14:58,815 --> 00:15:01,860
Do you remember bringing
a food tray to Michael Sutter?

331
00:15:01,901 --> 00:15:04,738
Michael? Sure. Nice family.

332
00:15:04,779 --> 00:15:06,656
Who'd you hand the tray to?

333
00:15:06,698 --> 00:15:08,283
I don't remember.

334
00:15:08,325 --> 00:15:10,368
I might
have just put it
on his bed table.

335
00:15:10,410 --> 00:15:13,371
Did you happen
to notice if his mother
did anything to his food?

336
00:15:13,413 --> 00:15:15,540
No, I don't remember
seeing her.

337
00:15:15,582 --> 00:15:16,708
Okay. Thanks, Martha.

338
00:15:16,750 --> 00:15:17,792
Any visitors?

339
00:15:17,834 --> 00:15:19,336
I don't know.
People come, people go.

340
00:15:19,377 --> 00:15:20,462
I don't much notice.

341
00:15:20,503 --> 00:15:21,504
What about
the food cart?

342
00:15:21,546 --> 00:15:22,672
You notice anybody
messing with it?

343
00:15:22,714 --> 00:15:25,592
Nobody. That I'd notice.
Excuse me.

344
00:15:28,595 --> 00:15:31,347
The girl doesn't remember
seeing Mrs. Sutter
near the food.

345
00:15:31,389 --> 00:15:32,682
Well, somebody
had to feed the kid.

346
00:15:32,724 --> 00:15:34,601
And somebody had
to see them do it.

347
00:15:34,642 --> 00:15:37,687
There are two beds
in the room.

348
00:15:37,729 --> 00:15:40,690
I've had too many
difficult days lately.

349
00:15:40,732 --> 00:15:44,778
Dialysis once a week
for two years.

350
00:15:44,819 --> 00:15:46,738
Just like the Sutter boy.

351
00:15:46,780 --> 00:15:48,782
Last Tuesday,
he was in your room

352
00:15:48,823 --> 00:15:52,327
at Hudson Terrace,
the next bed.

353
00:15:52,369 --> 00:15:53,662
Plays his TV too loud.

354
00:15:53,703 --> 00:15:55,705
You recall
you both ate lunch
in your room that day?

355
00:15:55,747 --> 00:16:00,210
I certainly do.
Meatloaf. Too dry.

356
00:16:00,794 --> 00:16:03,880
I hate dietetic pudding.

357
00:16:03,922 --> 00:16:07,467
You know, Michael can't
even wipe his own chin.

358
00:16:07,509 --> 00:16:08,885
On Tuesday,
you remember seeing

359
00:16:08,927 --> 00:16:10,887
Michael's mother
feed him his lunch?

360
00:16:10,929 --> 00:16:12,389
No, I don't.

361
00:16:13,556 --> 00:16:15,683
His father fed him.

362
00:16:15,725 --> 00:16:18,269
He cared enough
to bring something

363
00:16:18,311 --> 00:16:21,439
with a little taste
to put on the food.

364
00:16:21,523 --> 00:16:23,733
Lord knows, it needs it.

365
00:16:23,775 --> 00:16:26,945
The stuff
he put on the food,
what did it look like?

366
00:16:26,986 --> 00:16:30,949
I couldn't really see it.
He said it was cinnamon.

367
00:16:34,911 --> 00:16:37,664
Hemlock?
What's that got to
do with Joe Sutter?

368
00:16:37,706 --> 00:16:38,873
Well, it grows wild.

369
00:16:38,915 --> 00:16:40,542
You're in
the landscape business.

370
00:16:40,583 --> 00:16:41,626
He works for you.

371
00:16:41,668 --> 00:16:42,711
Yeah, for nine years.

372
00:16:42,752 --> 00:16:43,962
Helped turn
my business around.

373
00:16:44,004 --> 00:16:45,630
Nobody worked
harder than Joe.

374
00:16:45,672 --> 00:16:47,090
Worked?
When did he
stop working hard?

375
00:16:47,132 --> 00:16:50,593
His kid's condition
made it impossible for
him to pull a full week.

376
00:16:50,635 --> 00:16:52,345
He resent that?

377
00:16:52,387 --> 00:16:53,972
I resented that.

378
00:16:54,014 --> 00:16:56,641
When I heard
the kid died,

379
00:16:56,683 --> 00:16:58,643
part of me
actually felt relief.

380
00:16:58,685 --> 00:17:01,563
I get Joe back,
he gets his life back.

381
00:17:01,604 --> 00:17:03,606
Well, if I had a kid
like Michael,

382
00:17:03,648 --> 00:17:05,567
I wouldn't want
to see him suffering.

383
00:17:05,608 --> 00:17:07,986
Is that how Joe felt?
Who wouldn't?

384
00:17:08,028 --> 00:17:11,364
One time, after work,
Joe hoisted a few too many.

385
00:17:11,406 --> 00:17:13,992
Said he wished he'd
never breathed air
into his kid.

386
00:17:14,034 --> 00:17:17,078
Said he didn't save Michael,
only pieces of him.

387
00:17:17,120 --> 00:17:20,623
So the hemlock, would
Joe know where to find it?

388
00:17:20,665 --> 00:17:22,000
Any one of us
could find it.
Why?

389
00:17:22,042 --> 00:17:25,128
We're gonna need a list
of Sutter's last few
projects, all right?

390
00:17:25,170 --> 00:17:26,379
Yeah.

391
00:17:26,421 --> 00:17:29,966
You're backed
up against a wall.
Your life's falling apart.

392
00:17:30,008 --> 00:17:34,596
It was somebody else.
The hospital.

393
00:17:34,637 --> 00:17:36,347
I mean, they kept
changing the nurses,

394
00:17:36,389 --> 00:17:38,975
and then they stuck us
with this doctor, Semenko.

395
00:17:39,017 --> 00:17:40,810
I mean,
they didn't
give a damn.

396
00:17:40,852 --> 00:17:44,105
They had no reason to
want to see him dead.
You did.

397
00:17:44,147 --> 00:17:46,441
Look what's happened
to your beautiful family.

398
00:17:46,483 --> 00:17:48,485
Your wife's sleeping
with some dance teacher,

399
00:17:48,526 --> 00:17:50,695
your daughter's
one step away from
living on the street,

400
00:17:50,737 --> 00:17:53,114
and you have no money,
and all because of that kid.

401
00:17:53,156 --> 00:17:53,865
You don't know me.

402
00:17:53,907 --> 00:17:55,992
If you knew me,
you would see.

403
00:17:56,034 --> 00:17:57,494
I know you.

404
00:17:57,535 --> 00:17:58,745
If you had the stones...

405
00:17:58,787 --> 00:18:02,082
You don't know
this man, Lennie.

406
00:18:02,123 --> 00:18:03,958
Look, this isn't
about money or
adultery

407
00:18:04,000 --> 00:18:06,044
or anything like that,
is it, Joe?

408
00:18:11,174 --> 00:18:13,093
My wife's got MS.

409
00:18:15,887 --> 00:18:19,766
I picture her life
10 years from now
and it kills me

410
00:18:20,934 --> 00:18:22,852
because it might
not be a pretty picture.

411
00:18:24,104 --> 00:18:26,481
You see your boy,
he used to be strong.

412
00:18:26,523 --> 00:18:28,191
Played soccer, yeah?
Yes.

413
00:18:28,233 --> 00:18:31,528
My wife used to
run three miles
every morning.

414
00:18:35,490 --> 00:18:40,870
Did you imagine Michael at
20 years old? Forty years old?

415
00:18:40,912 --> 00:18:46,084
Still in that same room,
same bed, same tortured pain?

416
00:18:46,126 --> 00:18:47,419
Yeah.

417
00:18:48,586 --> 00:18:51,047
Me, too.

418
00:18:51,089 --> 00:18:54,426
And you want to
know the worst thing?
I know why it's happening.

419
00:18:55,802 --> 00:18:57,595
It's my fault.

420
00:18:57,637 --> 00:18:59,848
God is punishing her
because of something
I did.

421
00:18:59,889 --> 00:19:02,976
No. No, see, you cannot
think like that.

422
00:19:04,144 --> 00:19:06,479
I tell myself that, but...

423
00:19:07,564 --> 00:19:10,775
Every time
I look at her,
I feel the guilt.

424
00:19:10,817 --> 00:19:12,235
Every time I think of her,

425
00:19:12,277 --> 00:19:16,614
every time I think of
my daughters and what
they're going to lose.

426
00:19:16,656 --> 00:19:18,992
Someone you love
is suffering.

427
00:19:21,619 --> 00:19:23,830
They have no hope.

428
00:19:23,872 --> 00:19:26,124
What can you do
to help this person?

429
00:19:26,166 --> 00:19:29,753
I mean, how often have
you asked yourself
this question?

430
00:19:29,794 --> 00:19:31,629
When you bathe him?

431
00:19:32,922 --> 00:19:36,217
Every time
I kissed him good night.

432
00:19:36,259 --> 00:19:39,179
And you knew there
was only one answer.

433
00:19:41,473 --> 00:19:43,099
You had to do it.

434
00:19:43,141 --> 00:19:45,518
You had to do it
because you loved him.

435
00:19:50,607 --> 00:19:52,025
Let it go.

436
00:19:54,819 --> 00:19:57,155
It was an act of love, Joe.

437
00:20:00,241 --> 00:20:02,035
I loved Michael.

438
00:20:06,039 --> 00:20:08,041
All right, maybe I...

439
00:20:12,671 --> 00:20:15,548
But I didn't do this.

440
00:20:17,967 --> 00:20:19,636
I didn't kill him.

441
00:20:22,055 --> 00:20:23,932
I thought Curtis had him.

442
00:20:23,973 --> 00:20:25,433
Three months ago,

443
00:20:25,475 --> 00:20:29,145
Sutter spent
a week replanting the median
on the Southern State Parkway.

444
00:20:29,187 --> 00:20:31,022
Forensics
surveyed the area.

445
00:20:31,064 --> 00:20:34,651
"Conium maculatum.
Hemlock, two acres
scattered growth,

446
00:20:34,693 --> 00:20:37,028
"30 meters east of
construction site."

447
00:20:37,070 --> 00:20:39,072
Not exactly
a smoking gun.

448
00:20:39,114 --> 00:20:42,117
We've got motive,
access to the exact poison,

449
00:20:42,158 --> 00:20:45,662
a witness
to the feeding.
They can't all confess.

450
00:20:50,750 --> 00:20:51,835
Can I leave now?

451
00:20:51,876 --> 00:20:55,005
Not for about
another 30 years.

452
00:20:55,046 --> 00:20:57,173
You're
under arrest for
the murder of your son.

453
00:20:57,215 --> 00:20:58,633
You have the right to
remain silent.

454
00:20:58,675 --> 00:21:01,594
Anything you do say can
and will be used against you
in a court of law.

455
00:21:01,636 --> 00:21:04,764
You have
the right to an attorney.
If you cannot afford one...

456
00:21:09,978 --> 00:21:11,771
Mr. Sutter's
not a flight risk.

457
00:21:11,813 --> 00:21:13,523
His only family's
here in New York.

458
00:21:13,565 --> 00:21:15,817
He's charged with
killing a member
of that family.

459
00:21:15,859 --> 00:21:17,736
Even if we accept
the People's allegations,

460
00:21:17,777 --> 00:21:20,822
Mr. Sutter can't be
considered a threat
to the community.

461
00:21:20,864 --> 00:21:24,200
Bail is set at $100,000.
Next case.

462
00:21:26,161 --> 00:21:29,039
"Docket number
661254..."

463
00:21:29,080 --> 00:21:32,208
Excuse me.
Who do I see
about posting bail?

464
00:21:32,250 --> 00:21:33,251
Who are you?

465
00:21:33,293 --> 00:21:34,085
Roy Cashman.

466
00:21:34,127 --> 00:21:36,087
You're posting bail
for Joe Sutter?

467
00:21:36,171 --> 00:21:37,088
Yeah, so what?

468
00:21:37,130 --> 00:21:39,758
I have you down as
a prosecution witness.

469
00:21:39,799 --> 00:21:43,178
You told the police he said
he wished he'd never saved
his son.

470
00:21:43,178 --> 00:21:45,764
I never said
anything like that.

471
00:21:45,805 --> 00:21:47,849
Look, I know what
Joe is going through.

472
00:21:47,891 --> 00:21:50,977
I'm not going to
help you put him
in jail.

473
00:21:52,812 --> 00:21:54,981
Cashman's going to
testify for Sutter.

474
00:21:55,023 --> 00:21:56,941
Briscoe and Curtis can rebut.

475
00:21:56,983 --> 00:22:00,820
Plus, we've got two others
who confirm Sutter wanted
the boy dead.

476
00:22:00,862 --> 00:22:03,114
I spoke to the kid's
doctor, Lyle Semenko.

477
00:22:03,156 --> 00:22:04,783
He's backing off, too.

478
00:22:04,866 --> 00:22:08,620
This father kills his kid,
and the world still
loves him.

479
00:22:08,662 --> 00:22:11,247
They think
he committed
an act of mercy.

480
00:22:11,289 --> 00:22:16,086
Character witnesses, Cashman,
Semenko, none of it matters.

481
00:22:16,127 --> 00:22:18,088
Who told us his
father spiked
the food?

482
00:22:18,129 --> 00:22:20,340
That's your witness
to nail down.

483
00:22:23,051 --> 00:22:25,929
Miss Goring told me
I didn't have to
talk to you.

484
00:22:25,970 --> 00:22:29,641
She was wrong.
What did you tell her?

485
00:22:29,682 --> 00:22:33,269
That I was in the room
when Mr. Sutter was
feeding Michael.

486
00:22:33,311 --> 00:22:36,731
That he didn't do
anything to the food.

487
00:22:36,773 --> 00:22:40,360
You told her?
Or she told you?

488
00:22:42,445 --> 00:22:46,783
I'm pretty
sure about it.
I was in the room.

489
00:22:48,368 --> 00:22:52,664
Mrs. Bing says
she saw Mr. Sutter
spike Michael's food.

490
00:22:52,706 --> 00:22:55,000
She also
doesn't remember
you being in the room.

491
00:22:55,083 --> 00:22:58,086
Maybe Mrs. Bing's wrong.

492
00:22:58,128 --> 00:23:01,297
Martha,
Miss Goring's job
is protecting murderers.

493
00:23:02,090 --> 00:23:03,299
You're helping her do that.

494
00:23:03,341 --> 00:23:05,260
I used to talk to
the Sutters all the time.

495
00:23:05,301 --> 00:23:07,929
I saw the way
they were with Michael.

496
00:23:07,971 --> 00:23:09,305
They loved Michael.

497
00:23:11,850 --> 00:23:14,144
I see Martha McSorley
all the time.

498
00:23:14,185 --> 00:23:16,646
She works hard,
but she cares
too much.

499
00:23:16,688 --> 00:23:19,441
Whenever
somebody dies,
it becomes personal.

500
00:23:19,482 --> 00:23:21,985
She says she stayed
in the Sutters' room
right through lunch.

501
00:23:22,027 --> 00:23:26,406
She's got 30 trays
to deliver. You know
how much time that takes?

502
00:23:26,448 --> 00:23:28,700
No way she can hang out
in one patient's room

503
00:23:28,742 --> 00:23:30,243
and deliver
all those trays.

504
00:23:30,285 --> 00:23:32,328
No way she could do it,
or you know she didn't
do it?

505
00:23:32,370 --> 00:23:35,290
You told the police
you saw her during
her rounds.

506
00:23:35,332 --> 00:23:37,709
You're gonna
want me to testify?

507
00:23:37,751 --> 00:23:39,085
That's the idea.

508
00:23:40,211 --> 00:23:43,006
Guess I can't
say for sure.
It was quiet.

509
00:23:43,048 --> 00:23:45,175
I snuck out to the
stairwell for a smoke.

510
00:23:45,216 --> 00:23:47,218
Then how do you know
nobody tampered with
the food?

511
00:23:47,260 --> 00:23:48,678
'Cause nobody could have.

512
00:23:48,720 --> 00:23:52,223
'Cause when I ducked out,
there was a doctor
standing by the food cart

513
00:23:52,265 --> 00:23:55,477
doing some paperwork.
He was still there
when I came back.

514
00:23:55,518 --> 00:23:58,855
Nobody's gonna
mess with trays while
a doctor's right there.

515
00:23:58,897 --> 00:24:00,357
Do you remember which doctor?

516
00:24:00,398 --> 00:24:02,067
Dr. Semenko.

517
00:24:05,070 --> 00:24:06,738
McSorley's
definitely lying.

518
00:24:06,780 --> 00:24:09,783
We've got
a bigger problem.
Dr. Semenko's lying, too.

519
00:24:10,408 --> 00:24:11,743
The boy's doctor?

520
00:24:11,785 --> 00:24:14,871
An orderly said he saw
Semenko hanging around
the food cart

521
00:24:14,913 --> 00:24:16,456
while McSorley
was making her rounds.

522
00:24:16,498 --> 00:24:18,833
Semenko told
Briscoe and Curtis
he was out of the building.

523
00:24:18,875 --> 00:24:20,794
You sure he didn't
just forget where
he was?

524
00:24:20,835 --> 00:24:22,754
I just hope
we didn't put the Sutters

525
00:24:22,796 --> 00:24:25,006
through the wringer
for nothing.

526
00:24:25,048 --> 00:24:29,219
Talk to Semenko's boss.
Find out if he's just
absent-minded.

527
00:24:33,139 --> 00:24:34,349
Semenko's
a good physician.

528
00:24:34,391 --> 00:24:36,476
Well-liked, hard-working,
responsible.

529
00:24:36,518 --> 00:24:39,521
Even Dr. Schweitzer
had his detractors.

530
00:24:39,562 --> 00:24:43,817
Well, there
was one complaint.
About three months ago.

531
00:24:43,858 --> 00:24:46,236
A young woman badly
injured in a car accident.

532
00:24:46,277 --> 00:24:48,905
She'd been here four days,
seemed to be out of danger,

533
00:24:48,947 --> 00:24:50,073
then she just died.

534
00:24:50,115 --> 00:24:51,908
Unexplained
respiratory
failure.

535
00:24:51,950 --> 00:24:54,077
She was in
Dr. Semenko's care?

536
00:24:54,119 --> 00:24:56,413
She was under the care
of several specialists.

537
00:24:56,454 --> 00:24:58,915
Dr. Semenko
wasn't even
her primary.

538
00:24:58,957 --> 00:25:00,291
What was the conclusion?

539
00:25:00,333 --> 00:25:03,378
An investigation determined
the patient died of natural
causes.

540
00:25:03,420 --> 00:25:04,963
Stuff like that just happens.

541
00:25:05,005 --> 00:25:06,965
Whose investigation?
Ours.

542
00:25:07,007 --> 00:25:09,884
And you never thought
to mention any of this
to the police?

543
00:25:09,926 --> 00:25:12,804
Our counsel advised
we were under
no legal obligation.

544
00:25:12,846 --> 00:25:15,390
And like I said, Semenko
and the others were cleared.

545
00:25:15,390 --> 00:25:18,184
Just this one incident?
How long has he worked here?

546
00:25:18,226 --> 00:25:20,061
A little over six months.

547
00:25:20,103 --> 00:25:22,188
But I think you're
barking up the wrong tree.

548
00:25:22,230 --> 00:25:23,648
Where did
he work before Hudson?

549
00:25:23,690 --> 00:25:27,444
Bergen County
Clinical in New Jersey.
He came highly recommended.

550
00:25:28,570 --> 00:25:29,988
It was a mutual decision.

551
00:25:30,030 --> 00:25:33,408
We were facing cutbacks.
Dr. Semenko wanted to
move to the city.

552
00:25:33,408 --> 00:25:34,868
The fact that
his mortality rate

553
00:25:34,909 --> 00:25:37,245
was 14 times that of
any other staff physician

554
00:25:37,287 --> 00:25:39,205
had nothing
to do with your
decision to cut him loose?

555
00:25:39,247 --> 00:25:40,081
How did you know...

556
00:25:40,123 --> 00:25:42,167
I just came from
the County Coroner.

557
00:25:44,294 --> 00:25:47,172
A 61-year-old woman
has gallbladder surgery,

558
00:25:47,213 --> 00:25:49,174
a 17-year-old boy
having back surgery,

559
00:25:49,257 --> 00:25:50,884
and about
a half dozen others.

560
00:25:50,925 --> 00:25:52,510
None of them had
life-threatening
problems.

561
00:25:52,552 --> 00:25:56,181
All of them were
treated by Dr. Semenko,
and now they're all dead.

562
00:25:56,222 --> 00:25:58,099
He was cleared of
any malpractice charges.

563
00:25:58,099 --> 00:26:00,226
We're talking about murder.

564
00:26:00,268 --> 00:26:03,271
He was cleared in each of
the incidents you mentioned.

565
00:26:03,313 --> 00:26:05,899
By your own
impartial review board?

566
00:26:05,940 --> 00:26:09,444
The primary concern
of this hospital
is our patients' well-being.

567
00:26:09,486 --> 00:26:11,988
If one of our doctors
is a danger,

568
00:26:12,030 --> 00:26:13,531
we want to deal
with the problem.

569
00:26:13,573 --> 00:26:16,284
By passing it along
to the next hospital.

570
00:26:16,326 --> 00:26:19,371
Dr. Semenko is
a responsible physician.

571
00:26:19,412 --> 00:26:21,289
I've watched him work.

572
00:26:21,331 --> 00:26:23,375
When his patients
suffered setbacks,

573
00:26:23,416 --> 00:26:26,044
he always compiled
complete case studies.

574
00:26:26,086 --> 00:26:27,504
He attended
every postmortem.

575
00:26:27,545 --> 00:26:30,006
And yet
his patients
kept right on dying.

576
00:26:30,048 --> 00:26:33,218
You can't predict
an appendix patient
having an aneurysm.

577
00:26:33,259 --> 00:26:37,013
You can't
predict a high school senior
suffering nicotine poisoning.

578
00:26:37,055 --> 00:26:39,307
Nicotine poisoning?
It happens.

579
00:26:39,349 --> 00:26:41,559
There's no
way Dr. Semenko
could have known.

580
00:26:41,601 --> 00:26:44,938
The boy's parents
didn't even know
he used tobacco.

581
00:26:54,114 --> 00:26:55,532
Nice botany books, Doc.

582
00:26:55,573 --> 00:26:58,284
Anything in here on
how to grow poison
hemlock?

583
00:26:58,326 --> 00:27:00,286
I'm surprised
you don't seize
my anatomy books

584
00:27:00,328 --> 00:27:01,663
and arrest me
on porno charges.

585
00:27:01,705 --> 00:27:05,291
Got stuff here
looks like oregano.
Smells like oregano, too.

586
00:27:05,333 --> 00:27:06,251
And is oregano.

587
00:27:06,292 --> 00:27:08,461
If you're making
pasta later,
take some.

588
00:27:08,503 --> 00:27:10,505
No other greens except
for some Romaine lettuce

589
00:27:10,547 --> 00:27:11,673
that I can tell you
is for real.

590
00:27:11,715 --> 00:27:15,009
But you can get rid of it.
You got no snap in your stems.

591
00:27:15,051 --> 00:27:16,636
Can I have my home
back now?

592
00:27:16,678 --> 00:27:18,346
Hey, Doc,

593
00:27:18,388 --> 00:27:19,556
where do you
keep this baby?

594
00:27:19,597 --> 00:27:21,516
We'd like to take
a look under the hood.

595
00:27:21,558 --> 00:27:22,517
I don't own a car.

596
00:27:22,559 --> 00:27:24,477
You just collect the manuals?

597
00:27:24,519 --> 00:27:25,645
I sold that car.

598
00:27:26,354 --> 00:27:29,065
What's this? "Car-Finder."

599
00:27:29,107 --> 00:27:30,650
This one of
those satellite
locating systems?

600
00:27:30,692 --> 00:27:33,737
It was an expensive car.
I was concerned about
it getting stolen.

601
00:27:33,778 --> 00:27:36,698
Well, why don't we
activate the system,
see what turns up?

602
00:27:39,659 --> 00:27:44,330
Lake Hill Country Club.
Dr. Lyle Semenko.

603
00:27:44,372 --> 00:27:46,124
What, you threw the
clubs in with the car?

604
00:27:46,166 --> 00:27:48,668
Hey, Lennie, what's this?
More oregano?

605
00:27:52,005 --> 00:27:54,299
Wouldn't want to
sprinkle this on
my pasta.

606
00:27:54,340 --> 00:27:55,467
Unless you want some.

607
00:27:55,508 --> 00:27:57,177
You're under arrest
for murder, Doc.

608
00:27:57,218 --> 00:27:58,511
You have the right
to remain silent.

609
00:27:58,553 --> 00:28:01,598
Anything you say can
and will be used against you
in a court of law.

610
00:28:04,017 --> 00:28:05,477
You've
got no witnesses.

611
00:28:05,518 --> 00:28:07,062
You've got no
forensic evidence

612
00:28:07,062 --> 00:28:08,938
linking my client to
Michael Sutter's food.

613
00:28:08,980 --> 00:28:11,066
We've got poison hemlock
in his car.

614
00:28:11,107 --> 00:28:13,318
I'd love to hear his
explanation for that.

615
00:28:13,360 --> 00:28:16,279
You and I both know that
the jury will crucify him.

616
00:28:17,197 --> 00:28:19,240
Murder two. He does 25.

617
00:28:19,240 --> 00:28:22,118
Your client
took the life of
a defenseless child.

618
00:28:22,160 --> 00:28:22,869
What life?

619
00:28:22,911 --> 00:28:26,122
That boy was
in constant pain.

620
00:28:26,164 --> 00:28:30,293
You want us to start weighing
crimes based on the value of
the victim?

621
00:28:32,087 --> 00:28:35,465
I had
a 95-year-old
client in Florida.

622
00:28:35,507 --> 00:28:38,385
Shot his agonizing,
cancer-ridden wife
to death.

623
00:28:39,302 --> 00:28:42,013
Jury hit him with a $50 fine.

624
00:28:42,055 --> 00:28:44,474
This jury's gonna
know that Dr. Semenko

625
00:28:44,516 --> 00:28:47,018
was acting out of compassion
for the victim.

626
00:28:47,060 --> 00:28:50,105
I think your client's shown
a little too much compassion.

627
00:28:50,105 --> 00:28:52,148
We've looked into
his employment history.

628
00:28:52,190 --> 00:28:56,486
I estimate he's responsible
for 17 deaths at four
different hospitals.

629
00:28:56,528 --> 00:29:00,198
The hospitals
let him skate by,
but the buck stops here.

630
00:29:01,574 --> 00:29:03,368
Get your affairs in order.

631
00:29:03,410 --> 00:29:05,328
We're going to trial.

632
00:29:05,370 --> 00:29:08,415
You're spending the rest
of your life behind bars.

633
00:29:10,542 --> 00:29:12,585
Mercy killing.

634
00:29:12,627 --> 00:29:14,546
It worked for Dr. Kevorkian.

635
00:29:14,587 --> 00:29:16,339
This guy's no Kevorkian.

636
00:29:17,757 --> 00:29:19,801
I'm giving you my opinion
without having met the guy,

637
00:29:19,801 --> 00:29:21,428
but he sounds
like what we call

638
00:29:21,469 --> 00:29:24,556
a custodial poisoner
or asphyxiator.

639
00:29:24,597 --> 00:29:26,474
Plain vanilla
serial killer?

640
00:29:26,516 --> 00:29:29,561
A little more
charming than most,
but yeah.

641
00:29:29,602 --> 00:29:32,188
He rubbernecked at
every patient's
postmortem,

642
00:29:32,230 --> 00:29:36,151
like a kid
torturing a bug
and watching it die.

643
00:29:36,192 --> 00:29:40,530
And these deaths.
Starts with ODs on
prescription medicines.

644
00:29:40,572 --> 00:29:43,241
Then he gets bolder,
uses poisons.

645
00:29:43,283 --> 00:29:46,119
Stuffs bandages
down some lady's throat.

646
00:29:46,161 --> 00:29:48,455
He didn't get charged
on that one?

647
00:29:48,496 --> 00:29:50,123
Half a dozen of the staff
had access to the patient.

648
00:29:50,165 --> 00:29:52,250
The hospital
just fired them all.

649
00:29:52,292 --> 00:29:54,586
You don't think Semenko
wanted to get caught?

650
00:29:54,669 --> 00:29:56,671
No.

651
00:29:56,713 --> 00:29:59,632
No, he got bolder because
he got more confident.

652
00:29:59,674 --> 00:30:01,384
He believed he was
operating above
the rules.

653
00:30:01,426 --> 00:30:04,387
When nobody caught him,
everything got reinforced.

654
00:30:04,429 --> 00:30:06,473
We haven't caught him
yet, either.

655
00:30:06,514 --> 00:30:08,433
Motion in limine.

656
00:30:08,475 --> 00:30:10,435
Semenko's lawyer
wants to preclude

657
00:30:10,477 --> 00:30:12,395
any mention of
the other deaths.

658
00:30:12,729 --> 00:30:14,272
Oh, yeah.

659
00:30:17,609 --> 00:30:19,194
A doctor
has a run of bad luck,

660
00:30:19,235 --> 00:30:20,612
but that does not
make him a killer.

661
00:30:20,653 --> 00:30:22,572
Bad luck had
nothing to do with this.

662
00:30:22,614 --> 00:30:24,282
Mr. Semenko is
a serial killer.

663
00:30:24,324 --> 00:30:27,535
He was never charged
in those other deaths.

664
00:30:27,535 --> 00:30:28,787
Your Honor,
People v. Molineux.

665
00:30:28,828 --> 00:30:31,581
They are prior bad acts.
The evidence is not
admissible.

666
00:30:31,623 --> 00:30:33,083
It's not even relevant,
Mr. McCoy.

667
00:30:33,124 --> 00:30:35,835
People v. Mees.
These acts establish motive.

668
00:30:35,877 --> 00:30:38,505
The defendant is trying
to convince a jury

669
00:30:38,546 --> 00:30:40,423
that he acted out of mercy

670
00:30:40,465 --> 00:30:44,260
when he has
a track record of killing
perfectly healthy patients.

671
00:30:44,302 --> 00:30:47,138
Molineux,  even
as extended by  Mees,

672
00:30:47,180 --> 00:30:49,307
allows only
similar prior bad acts.

673
00:30:49,349 --> 00:30:51,267
Not one of
these other deaths
involved a patient

674
00:30:51,309 --> 00:30:53,770
who had zero expectation
of recovery.

675
00:30:53,812 --> 00:30:55,188
This is perverse!

676
00:30:55,230 --> 00:30:59,567
Mr. Gillum is saying that
because this killer never
showed mercy,

677
00:30:59,609 --> 00:31:03,446
he should be allowed to argue
that he's a mercy killer
this time.

678
00:31:03,488 --> 00:31:05,365
You have a point, Mr. McCoy.

679
00:31:05,407 --> 00:31:08,785
But this doesn't meet
the Molineux exceptions.

680
00:31:08,827 --> 00:31:11,204
And if
I have to choose
between an A.D.A.

681
00:31:11,246 --> 00:31:13,707
and the Court of Appeals,
guess who wins?

682
00:31:14,499 --> 00:31:16,835
The evidence
is suppressed.

683
00:31:21,339 --> 00:31:24,551
Michael Sutter was
murdered by the defendant.

684
00:31:26,928 --> 00:31:29,389
This is not in dispute.

685
00:31:31,725 --> 00:31:35,812
The defense will
give you reasons why
it's not a bad thing.

686
00:31:37,188 --> 00:31:41,401
They'll tell you
that Michael Sutter
had no quality of life.

687
00:31:43,528 --> 00:31:47,282
It's true that Michael Sutter
wasn't going to grow up to be

688
00:31:47,324 --> 00:31:51,411
a teacher or an engineer or
a doctor, like the defendant.

689
00:31:52,787 --> 00:31:54,914
But he liked to watch TV.

690
00:31:55,874 --> 00:31:57,917
He loved his family.

691
00:31:58,877 --> 00:32:00,920
And he was alive.

692
00:32:02,464 --> 00:32:04,716
The defense will tell you

693
00:32:04,758 --> 00:32:09,179
that taking
Michael Sutter's life
was the merciful thing to do.

694
00:32:09,220 --> 00:32:12,932
Michael Sutter's family
will tell you that they
loved Michael.

695
00:32:14,851 --> 00:32:16,811
They miss Michael.

696
00:32:20,357 --> 00:32:25,278
This case
is not a debate
about euthanasia.

697
00:32:26,988 --> 00:32:29,866
It's about a thrill
killing by a monster

698
00:32:29,908 --> 00:32:32,369
masquerading as
an angel of mercy.

699
00:32:35,830 --> 00:32:37,957
Michael Sutter is dead.

700
00:32:40,502 --> 00:32:44,547
He was murdered.
That's all that matters.

701
00:32:53,723 --> 00:32:55,934
Mr. McCoy is right,
the law is simple.

702
00:32:55,975 --> 00:32:57,977
It only sees
black and white.

703
00:32:58,853 --> 00:33:00,605
But reality?

704
00:33:00,647 --> 00:33:04,234
Well, reality has
all sorts of shades
of gray, doesn't it?

705
00:33:05,986 --> 00:33:08,405
Dr. Semenko didn't
just wake up one morning

706
00:33:08,446 --> 00:33:11,241
and on a whim decide
to kill Michael Sutter.

707
00:33:11,282 --> 00:33:13,451
Michael Sutter's
parents know that.

708
00:33:13,535 --> 00:33:15,745
And although
it may be very hard
for them to admit it,

709
00:33:15,787 --> 00:33:17,747
they wanted this death.

710
00:33:17,789 --> 00:33:21,501
And they made that
very clear to Dr. Semenko,

711
00:33:21,543 --> 00:33:25,380
who had the courage,
in the face of
an antiquated law,

712
00:33:25,422 --> 00:33:29,009
to act in the
best interests of
a suffering child.

713
00:33:30,552 --> 00:33:33,388
The State tries to
lock up people
like this.

714
00:33:33,430 --> 00:33:35,265
They have put
Dr. Jack Kevorkian
on trial

715
00:33:35,306 --> 00:33:39,728
over and over again,
but he's never been
convicted.

716
00:33:39,769 --> 00:33:43,356
Because juries,
juries just like you,

717
00:33:44,316 --> 00:33:46,943
have always
recognized the truth.

718
00:33:48,820 --> 00:33:52,449
Dr. Lyle Semenko
is not a criminal.

719
00:33:56,578 --> 00:33:57,954
He's a hero.

720
00:34:04,085 --> 00:34:06,629
I read him stories
every night.

721
00:34:07,630 --> 00:34:09,466
It's funny,

722
00:34:09,507 --> 00:34:12,385
he had the
same favorites
he did as a baby.

723
00:34:14,095 --> 00:34:18,600
After all
the suffering,
after all the damage,

724
00:34:20,769 --> 00:34:23,480
he was still
the same little boy.

725
00:34:23,521 --> 00:34:27,067
Did you love him,
Mr. Sutter?

726
00:34:27,108 --> 00:34:29,652
You don't stop
loving your son
when he gets hurt.

727
00:34:31,154 --> 00:34:34,616
And you don't stop
loving your son
when he dies.

728
00:34:34,657 --> 00:34:39,037
Mr. Sutter, did you
ever ask Dr. Semenko
to end your son's life?

729
00:34:39,079 --> 00:34:40,080
No.

730
00:34:40,955 --> 00:34:42,999
It's horrifying

731
00:34:44,084 --> 00:34:46,419
that he could
blame this on us.

732
00:34:47,962 --> 00:34:49,672
I mean, that anybody
could think

733
00:34:49,714 --> 00:34:51,675
that we wanted this.

734
00:34:59,808 --> 00:35:04,020
Mr. Sutter, Michael's care has
cost you almost a quarter
of a million dollars

735
00:35:04,062 --> 00:35:05,522
since the accident,
hasn't it?

736
00:35:06,439 --> 00:35:07,649
Whatever it was,
it was worth it.

737
00:35:07,691 --> 00:35:08,608
I understand.

738
00:35:08,650 --> 00:35:10,443
But you had
a college fund
for your daughter,

739
00:35:10,485 --> 00:35:11,903
and now
that's gone,
isn't that right?

740
00:35:11,987 --> 00:35:13,113
Yes.

741
00:35:13,154 --> 00:35:17,450
And your relationship with
your wife has grown strained?

742
00:35:18,118 --> 00:35:20,036
She was having an affair?

743
00:35:21,538 --> 00:35:24,165
Michael's condition made
things very difficult
for all of us.

744
00:35:24,207 --> 00:35:26,668
And he wasn't going
to get any better, was he?

745
00:35:26,710 --> 00:35:28,044
We hoped.

746
00:35:28,712 --> 00:35:29,713
But, no.

747
00:35:29,754 --> 00:35:31,589
In fact,
there was only one way

748
00:35:31,631 --> 00:35:33,133
that Michael's suffering
was going to end,

749
00:35:33,174 --> 00:35:34,676
and you knew that,
didn't you?

750
00:35:34,676 --> 00:35:35,677
No.

751
00:35:35,719 --> 00:35:37,721
I could never take...
Now, on December 12th,

752
00:35:37,762 --> 00:35:39,889
did you take Michael to
an appointment with
Dr. Semenko?

753
00:35:39,931 --> 00:35:42,058
I took Michael to
many appointments.

754
00:35:42,100 --> 00:35:46,563
And did you say to Dr. Semenko
that Michael didn't deserve
to live like this?

755
00:35:46,604 --> 00:35:49,149
Didn't you tell Dr. Semenko

756
00:35:49,190 --> 00:35:51,860
that you wished Michael's
suffering would end?

757
00:35:51,901 --> 00:35:54,070
No, I might
have said that,

758
00:35:54,112 --> 00:35:56,573
but I didn't mean
I wanted him dead.

759
00:35:56,614 --> 00:35:58,033
Mr. Sutter,

760
00:35:58,074 --> 00:35:59,367
if you had to do
it all over again,

761
00:35:59,409 --> 00:36:05,623
I mean, if you had known
how much Michael was
going to suffer,

762
00:36:05,665 --> 00:36:07,667
would you have
pulled him out
of that car?

763
00:36:09,836 --> 00:36:11,796
I loved Michael.

764
00:36:11,880 --> 00:36:13,840
I know that, Mr. Sutter.

765
00:36:14,924 --> 00:36:18,678
But would you
have saved his life?

766
00:36:27,937 --> 00:36:29,731
No.
Thank you.

767
00:36:33,693 --> 00:36:36,196
Do you remember
coming to the hospital
with your daughter Stephanie

768
00:36:36,237 --> 00:36:39,032
on a Saturday morning
last November?

769
00:36:39,074 --> 00:36:42,160
Michael woke up
with a fever of 103.

770
00:36:42,202 --> 00:36:44,788
It turned out
to be a flu virus.

771
00:36:44,829 --> 00:36:47,499
And did Stephanie want
to come to the hospital?

772
00:36:47,957 --> 00:36:49,417
Her brother was sick.

773
00:36:49,459 --> 00:36:52,545
Didn't she tell you that
she would rather be
skating with her friends?

774
00:36:52,587 --> 00:36:54,547
Objection.
He's leading
his own witness.

775
00:36:54,589 --> 00:36:55,882
Sustained.

776
00:36:55,924 --> 00:36:58,134
Did you fight
with your daughter at
the hospital?

777
00:36:59,135 --> 00:37:00,637
I don't recall.

778
00:37:00,679 --> 00:37:03,807
Do you
recall Dr. Semenko
being in the room

779
00:37:03,848 --> 00:37:05,684
when you were arguing
with Stephanie?

780
00:37:05,725 --> 00:37:07,644
Objection.
She doesn't recall arguing.

781
00:37:07,686 --> 00:37:10,230
A priori, she can't recall
who might have been present.

782
00:37:10,271 --> 00:37:12,691
Next question, Mr. Gillum.

783
00:37:12,732 --> 00:37:15,652
Your Honor,
permission to treat
this witness as hostile.

784
00:37:15,694 --> 00:37:16,987
Go ahead.

785
00:37:17,028 --> 00:37:19,864
Didn't Stephanie tell you
that she didn't give
a damn about Michael?

786
00:37:19,906 --> 00:37:22,283
That she had stuff to do?

787
00:37:22,325 --> 00:37:23,576
Objection. Hearsay.

788
00:37:23,618 --> 00:37:26,162
Offered to show the
defendant's state
of mind, Your Honor.

789
00:37:26,204 --> 00:37:29,249
Overruled.
The witness will answer.

790
00:37:31,751 --> 00:37:35,088
She might have
said some things
she shouldn't have.

791
00:37:35,130 --> 00:37:37,507
Like calling Michael
a vegetable?

792
00:37:37,549 --> 00:37:41,010
She was angry.
She wanted to hurt me.

793
00:37:41,052 --> 00:37:43,638
Wasn't she worried about
hurting her brother?

794
00:37:44,848 --> 00:37:46,683
He couldn't understand.

795
00:37:46,725 --> 00:37:48,184
Exactly.

796
00:37:48,226 --> 00:37:51,312
He couldn't
even understand
when his own sister said

797
00:37:51,354 --> 00:37:54,858
that she wished
he were dead,
could he?

798
00:37:54,899 --> 00:37:56,735
She didn't mean it.

799
00:37:56,776 --> 00:38:00,739
She just didn't want to
see Michael suffer anymore.

800
00:38:00,780 --> 00:38:01,865
None of us did.

801
00:38:03,074 --> 00:38:04,284
I know.

802
00:38:05,660 --> 00:38:06,786
Thank you.

803
00:38:08,830 --> 00:38:12,709
Mrs. Sutter, did you

804
00:38:12,751 --> 00:38:16,629
ever tell Dr. Semenko
to end Michael's life?

805
00:38:16,880 --> 00:38:17,881
No.

806
00:38:18,173 --> 00:38:19,632
Thank you.

807
00:38:23,636 --> 00:38:25,764
Dr. Semenko,
does Hudson Terrace
Hospital

808
00:38:25,805 --> 00:38:28,224
have a policy regarding
assisted suicide?

809
00:38:28,266 --> 00:38:32,228
Yes.
In all New York hospitals
it's strictly prohibited.

810
00:38:32,270 --> 00:38:34,731
And is this ever
a subject of discussion

811
00:38:34,773 --> 00:38:36,608
amongst your
fellow physicians?

812
00:38:36,650 --> 00:38:37,901
Frequently.

813
00:38:37,942 --> 00:38:40,278
The rules reflect
a wrong-headed view

814
00:38:40,320 --> 00:38:42,781
of dealing with
death and dying.

815
00:38:42,822 --> 00:38:45,992
Do you and your colleagues
have methods to get around
these rules?

816
00:38:46,034 --> 00:38:49,871
We physicians
risk being charged
with trafficking in drugs

817
00:38:49,913 --> 00:38:52,999
just by
providing morphine
to terminal patients.

818
00:38:53,041 --> 00:38:56,920
The State doesn't want us
to turn them into junkies.

819
00:38:56,961 --> 00:38:59,130
And every day, in every
hospital in this country,

820
00:38:59,172 --> 00:39:01,091
a doctor calls
for a slow code.

821
00:39:01,132 --> 00:39:03,677
Objection.
Contrary to what
the defendant thinks,

822
00:39:03,718 --> 00:39:05,220
he can't possibly
know what goes on

823
00:39:05,261 --> 00:39:07,097
in every hospital
in the country.

824
00:39:07,138 --> 00:39:09,057
Sustained.

825
00:39:09,057 --> 00:39:13,144
Dr. Semenko,
would you please
define the term "slow code"?

826
00:39:13,186 --> 00:39:17,732
When a patient is beyond hope
and requires life-saving
measures,

827
00:39:17,774 --> 00:39:21,027
a slow code means
the staff just goes
through the motions.

828
00:39:21,069 --> 00:39:22,821
They let the patient die.

829
00:39:22,862 --> 00:39:25,281
And this is
done according to the
patient's instructions?

830
00:39:25,323 --> 00:39:28,868
No, it's done when,
in the attending
physician's opinion,

831
00:39:28,910 --> 00:39:30,870
death would be best.

832
00:39:30,912 --> 00:39:32,330
Michael Sutter
wasn't terminal.

833
00:39:32,372 --> 00:39:35,333
He could
have lived another,
what, 50, 60 years?

834
00:39:35,375 --> 00:39:36,793
His heart would
have kept on beating,

835
00:39:36,835 --> 00:39:40,130
his lungs would
have kept on breathing,

836
00:39:40,171 --> 00:39:42,048
and the pain
would never stop.

837
00:39:44,759 --> 00:39:47,137
Sometimes
I have to tell people

838
00:39:47,178 --> 00:39:50,932
the worst news they
think they'll ever hear,

839
00:39:50,974 --> 00:39:52,851
the death of
their loved one.

840
00:39:52,892 --> 00:39:58,690
But somehow they wake up
the next morning,
and their life goes on.

841
00:39:58,732 --> 00:40:01,901
People couldn't function
if they couldn't move on.

842
00:40:03,153 --> 00:40:08,366
The Sutters
couldn't move on.
They needed to move on.

843
00:40:08,450 --> 00:40:12,287
Did the Sutters ask you
to end their son's life?

844
00:40:12,329 --> 00:40:14,372
There was no doubt
about what they wanted.

845
00:40:14,414 --> 00:40:16,458
They knew
their son's life,

846
00:40:16,458 --> 00:40:18,835
in any meaningful way,
was over.

847
00:40:18,877 --> 00:40:22,130
I was just the instrument,
doing what they wanted done.

848
00:40:22,172 --> 00:40:25,467
What they couldn't
bring themselves to do.

849
00:40:25,508 --> 00:40:28,094
Thank you, Doctor.
Your witness.

850
00:40:35,477 --> 00:40:36,936
Your Honor,
it's almost 12:00.

851
00:40:36,978 --> 00:40:39,773
I wonder if we could
take our noon recess?

852
00:40:41,775 --> 00:40:44,235
The jury's buying it.
Semenko's hammering us.

853
00:40:44,319 --> 00:40:47,030
He's smart,
he's confident,
he's charming.

854
00:40:47,072 --> 00:40:48,823
Same pathology that
makes him a serial killer

855
00:40:48,823 --> 00:40:50,116
makes him
a hell of a witness.

856
00:40:50,158 --> 00:40:52,786
He must have
some weakness.

857
00:40:52,827 --> 00:40:54,746
You ever once hear
him question
what he did?

858
00:40:54,788 --> 00:40:56,414
The Sutters
needed to move on.

859
00:40:56,456 --> 00:40:58,416
Absolute knowledge.
Absolute certainty.

860
00:40:58,458 --> 00:41:00,001
Some kind of God complex?

861
00:41:00,001 --> 00:41:01,419
His narcissism.

862
00:41:01,461 --> 00:41:03,880
Power to save life,
power to end life.

863
00:41:03,922 --> 00:41:05,382
More fascinated
with death.

864
00:41:05,423 --> 00:41:07,008
Jack,
somebody that's
in love with himself

865
00:41:07,050 --> 00:41:10,011
isn't going
to like having his
opinions challenged.

866
00:41:10,011 --> 00:41:12,055
He'll hate it.

867
00:41:12,097 --> 00:41:14,099
One weakness
he does have,

868
00:41:14,140 --> 00:41:16,059
he's not afraid of you.

869
00:41:17,602 --> 00:41:21,022
Mr. McCoy,
are you ready to proceed?

870
00:41:21,064 --> 00:41:22,148
Yes, Your Honor.

871
00:41:25,568 --> 00:41:30,073
Michael Sutter isn't the first
severely handicapped patient

872
00:41:30,115 --> 00:41:31,825
you've had in your care,
is he?

873
00:41:32,325 --> 00:41:33,910
No. I've had many.

874
00:41:35,078 --> 00:41:36,079
Did you kill them all?

875
00:41:36,621 --> 00:41:37,956
Objection!

876
00:41:37,998 --> 00:41:41,543
Sustained.
Watch your step, Mr. McCoy.

877
00:41:42,961 --> 00:41:44,212
I'll rephrase.

878
00:41:44,254 --> 00:41:48,091
When dealing
with other patients
with similar difficulties,

879
00:41:48,133 --> 00:41:52,053
how did you
justify allowing
some of them to live?

880
00:41:52,095 --> 00:41:54,973
Every case
must be assessed
on its own merits.

881
00:41:55,014 --> 00:41:57,976
By you? No need to
consult the family?

882
00:41:58,018 --> 00:42:00,979
The Sutters
had already made
their wishes known.

883
00:42:01,021 --> 00:42:03,565
But ultimately,
it was your decision,

884
00:42:03,606 --> 00:42:05,275
and you weren't
afraid to make it?

885
00:42:05,317 --> 00:42:06,818
I have the training.

886
00:42:06,860 --> 00:42:10,447
The training to decide
who should die, and when?

887
00:42:10,488 --> 00:42:14,993
The training to recognize
when there is no more hope.

888
00:42:15,035 --> 00:42:21,916
And did your training
tell you to use hemlock
to kill a helpless boy?

889
00:42:21,958 --> 00:42:25,462
Coniine,
the active ingredient,
causes the lungs to shut down.

890
00:42:25,503 --> 00:42:27,380
It's an effective
agent of death.

891
00:42:27,422 --> 00:42:30,091
It causes all muscles
to shut down.

892
00:42:30,133 --> 00:42:33,511
It's a horribly
painful death,
isn't it?

893
00:42:33,553 --> 00:42:36,139
My specialty is
spinal cord injuries.

894
00:42:36,181 --> 00:42:39,893
That's why
the Sutters chose me
to care for their boy.

895
00:42:40,935 --> 00:42:43,271
Michael's death was
relatively pain-free.

896
00:42:43,313 --> 00:42:44,898
Relatively?

897
00:42:47,108 --> 00:42:52,989
Wouldn't potassium
chloride have been quick
and completely pain-free?

898
00:42:54,366 --> 00:42:55,450
The difference is,

899
00:42:55,492 --> 00:42:56,993
that would have
raised red flags

900
00:42:57,035 --> 00:42:59,496
all around
the hospital,
isn't that right?

901
00:42:59,537 --> 00:43:02,499
If you're implying
that my medical opinion
was compromised

902
00:43:02,540 --> 00:43:06,169
by a desire not to be
detected, you're right.

903
00:43:06,211 --> 00:43:10,548
I would rather be in
a hospital right now,
caring for my patients,

904
00:43:10,632 --> 00:43:13,885
than defending
this ridiculous charge.

905
00:43:13,968 --> 00:43:17,263
But Michael Sutter's
death was humane.

906
00:43:17,305 --> 00:43:18,431
You have no doubt at all?

907
00:43:18,473 --> 00:43:21,101
No. It was the
right thing to do.

908
00:43:24,521 --> 00:43:26,481
Then why didn't
you come forward

909
00:43:26,481 --> 00:43:29,025
when Mr. Sutter was
charged with murder?

910
00:43:31,277 --> 00:43:33,029
Come on, Dr. Semenko.

911
00:43:33,071 --> 00:43:36,241
If you have
such confidence
in your own goodness,

912
00:43:36,282 --> 00:43:39,077
why let an innocent man
go to jail?

913
00:43:39,119 --> 00:43:40,036
Objection, Your Honor.

914
00:43:40,078 --> 00:43:41,621
Overruled.

915
00:43:41,663 --> 00:43:44,124
Dr. Semenko,
answer his question.

916
00:43:45,500 --> 00:43:46,751
I don't know.

917
00:43:46,793 --> 00:43:49,921
Is it because deep
in your heart you knew
what you did was wrong?

918
00:43:50,005 --> 00:43:52,298
That you had
committed murder?

919
00:43:56,261 --> 00:43:57,345
No more questions.

920
00:43:57,387 --> 00:43:59,055
No, I want to answer.

921
00:44:03,685 --> 00:44:07,021
I have confidence
in the judicial system.

922
00:44:07,063 --> 00:44:10,525
I knew Mr. Sutter
would be found innocent.

923
00:44:10,567 --> 00:44:12,902
If I stepped forward,
I'd lose my license.

924
00:44:12,944 --> 00:44:17,657
I'd lose my ability to
continue my work
to care for my patients.

925
00:44:22,579 --> 00:44:26,249
He's awfully slick.
The bastard.

926
00:44:26,291 --> 00:44:28,126
He said
the Sutters chose him.

927
00:44:28,209 --> 00:44:31,671
Joe Sutter told the police
the hospital assigned
Semenko to them.

928
00:44:31,713 --> 00:44:34,340
Maybe Semenko's lying,
trying to build himself up.

929
00:44:35,508 --> 00:44:37,052
Check it out.

930
00:44:41,014 --> 00:44:42,432
Has the jury reached
a verdict?

931
00:44:42,474 --> 00:44:44,351
Yes, we have,
Your Honor.

932
00:44:44,392 --> 00:44:46,227
On the first
count of the indictment,

933
00:44:46,269 --> 00:44:48,938
Murder in
the Second Degree,
how do you find?

934
00:44:48,980 --> 00:44:51,483
We find the defendant
not guilty.

935
00:44:51,566 --> 00:44:53,568
On the second
count of the indictment,

936
00:44:53,610 --> 00:44:56,196
Manslaughter in
the First Degree,
how do you find?

937
00:44:56,237 --> 00:44:58,657
We find
the defendant not guilty.

938
00:44:58,698 --> 00:45:01,076
And on the final
count of the indictment,

939
00:45:01,117 --> 00:45:04,204
Manslaughter in
the Second Degree,
how do you find?

940
00:45:04,245 --> 00:45:06,331
We find the defendant guilty.

941
00:45:24,307 --> 00:45:26,976
They're calling Semenko
the next Kevorkian.

942
00:45:27,018 --> 00:45:28,603
Read on.

943
00:45:28,645 --> 00:45:30,480
They've already
received donations

944
00:45:30,522 --> 00:45:32,482
for his appeal
from all 50 states.

945
00:45:32,524 --> 00:45:33,400
Yeah, well,
don't be surprised

946
00:45:33,441 --> 00:45:35,318
if the Sutters kick
in a few extra bucks.

947
00:45:35,360 --> 00:45:37,987
The hospital confirmed
Joe Sutter asked
for their son

948
00:45:38,029 --> 00:45:40,407
to be transferred
to Semenko's care.

949
00:45:40,448 --> 00:45:41,533
I don't want to hear this.

950
00:45:41,574 --> 00:45:43,493
I pulled
Lois Sutter's resume.

951
00:45:43,535 --> 00:45:46,788
Her last job,
she spent two days a week
at Bergen County Clinical.

952
00:45:46,830 --> 00:45:50,041
She was there for
five of Semenko's
suspicious deaths.

953
00:45:50,083 --> 00:45:53,169
They knew.
They put their kid in
front of a loaded gun.

954
00:45:53,211 --> 00:45:55,505
What are you
gonna do about it?

955
00:45:55,547 --> 00:45:58,633
You couldn't even convict
Semenko of murder.

956
00:45:59,384 --> 00:46:01,636
Who's joining me for dinner?


